Summary of reasons for partial acceptance or refusal
Having ruled out the hypothesis that their content is assumed as a prerequisite, in an executive way, for a subsequent administrative act, the documents subject to the request cannot be shown having as their object an act of the civil trial, (see among the many Council of State section IV, 19.01.2011); furthermore pursuant to art. 2 co. 1 letter b)9 and c) Prime Ministerial Decree 01/20/1996 n. 200, the defense documents as well as the correspondence inherent to an ongoing dispute are excluded from access, including the documentation received from the sponsored administrations in order to prepare the defenses (see TAR Lazio section I sentence no. 8264/2019).
